MSF Course Pain and Suffering

Main Motorcycle Forum - Motorcycles and related products and laws. 

Page 6 of 13       < 1 2 3 > last >> Bookmark this page:  YahooMyWeb Yahoo!  Google Google  Windows Live Favorites Windows Live  del.icio.us del.icio.us  digg digg  Add to Netscape Netscape
Subject Author Date
MSF Course Pain and Suffering David T. Ashley 09-22-2008
If you were  Registered and logged in, you could reply and use other advanced thread options
Posted by Twibil on September 22, 2008, 5:13 pm



> > The physics is exactly the same when it rains, it's just the limits tha=
t
> > are lower.
>
> I don't think so.

You're wrong.

> =A0The physics are similar, but not the same.

They are exactly the same.

> There is hydroplaning.

Surprise! Because they have tires with rounded profiles rather than
being flat on the bottoms like cage tires, motorcycles aren't prone to
hydroplaning unless (A) the bike's tires are bald, (B) the pavement is
submerged, not just wet, and (C) you're moving at a pretty good clip.
And none of these things would be true at a parking lot based training
session, much less all of them together.

Hydroplaning is out.


Posted by Bruce Richmond on September 22, 2008, 9:11 pm


>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> >> I told them that it was patently unfair to hold an MSF basic rider cou=
rse
> >> in
> >> the rain. =A0The issue in my mind is that for most motorcycles, the fr=
ont
> >> brake takes an awful lot of force to lock up on dry pavement. =A0In th=
e
> >> rain,
> >> it gets easier.
>
> >> Opinions? =A0Advice?
>
> > Would they accept a motorcycle license that prohibits riding in the
> > rain? If not, they should learn it, too.
>
> > The physics is exactly the same when it rains, it's just the limits tha=
t
> > are lower.
>
> I don't think so. =A0The physics are similar, but not the same.
>
> There is hydroplaning.

I can assure you there is no hydroplaning going on in a MSF class. We
race in the rain and it takes standing water and much higher speed
than you go in class to get a motorcycle to hydroplane.

> I also get the impression -- perhaps erroneous -- that the gap between
> static and kinetic friction is larger when the road is wet. =A0Once you g=
et
> the wheel a'sliding (rather than a'rolling), it doesn't always seem that
> easy to get it a'rolling again.- Hide quoted text -

Both go down in the wet. One thing that does make it tricky for new
riders is that when a disc brake gets wet it has reduced grip for a
few turns as the water gets wiped off. The grip then increases while
holding the same pressure on the lever. If the rider has increased
pressure because they weren't getting the grip they wanted they can
suddenly find the wheel locking up. Some brakes are worse than others
in this respect. One way to get around this problem is to frequently
drag the brake a bit. That wipes the water off and heats the disc up
so that any water that does get on it will evaporate quickly. If the
bike is particularly bad in this respect it can be improved with
different pads or drill patterns in the rotor.

The fact that both of them and others went down makes me wonder if the
students were adequately instructed on what to expect. On the street
in the wet I use a bit less front brake and a bit more rear brake than
I do in the dry, particularly if braking while turning.

Bruce


Bruce

> - Show quoted text -


Posted by Twibil on September 22, 2008, 3:16 am



(Snip typical Ashley foolishness)

> I told them that it was patently unfair to hold an MSF basic rider course=
in
> the rain. =A0The issue in my mind is that for most motorcycles, the front
> brake takes an awful lot of force to lock up on dry pavement. =A0In the r=
ain,
> it gets easier.
>
> Opinions? =A0Advice?

So you think that beginning riders shouldn't have to learn how to
brake in the wet as well as the dry?

Boggle.

That's on a par with not teaching kids about gun safety because you
think they'll be safer in ignorance.


Posted by High Plains Thumper on September 22, 2008, 6:31 am


Twibil wrote:
> "David T. Ashley" wrote:
>
> (Snip typical Ashley foolishness)
>
>> I told them that it was patently unfair to hold an MSF basic
>> rider course in the rain. The issue in my mind is that for
>> most motorcycles, the front brake takes an awful lot of
>> force to lock up on dry pavement. In the rain, it gets
>> easier. Opinions? Advice?
>
> So you think that beginning riders shouldn't have to learn how
> to brake in the wet as well as the dry? Boggle. That's on a
> par with not teaching kids about gun safety because you think
> they'll be safer in ignorance.

That guns cause deaths (instead of the idiot who pulled the
trigger) makes as much sense as helmetless riders cause accidents.

--
HPT

Posted by MikeWhy on September 22, 2008, 12:45 pm



> I told them that it was patently unfair to hold an MSF basic rider course
> in
> the rain. The issue in my mind is that for most motorcycles, the front
> brake takes an awful lot of force to lock up on dry pavement. In the rain,
> it gets easier.
>
> Opinions? Advice?

So you think that beginning riders shouldn't have to learn how to
brake in the wet as well as the dry?

Boggle.

That's on a par with not teaching kids about gun safety because you
think they'll be safer in ignorance.

-----
While I agree in principle with the thought, basic gun safety and range
procedure should be taught in carefully controlled conditions, not under
live fire.

The safety margin on slick pavement is too narrow for the new rider on
unfamiliar equipment. The truth of that is self-evident in the unnecessary
injuries. The flipside of the argument is that BRC taught strictly on dry
pavement is incomplete, by not including wet pavement. To that point, I
readily agree also. If wet braking is an important part of the course,
though, it should be taught and practiced in all sessions, not just those
that just happened to be held in the rain. Continuing the lessons in the
adverse conditions was for expedience only.



Page 6 of 13       < 1 2 3 > last >>
Similar ThreadsPosted
Re: ?? Where in the world is suffering and oppression worse than occupied Iraq ?? December 16, 2006, 9:23 am
PAIN PAIN GO AWAY COME AGAIN ANOTHER DAY.... May 14, 2008, 9:20 am
PAIN August 4, 2008, 8:12 am
Riding Cures Pain July 10, 2007, 11:29 pm
Re: Motorcycle batteries are a pain in the ass April 11, 2006, 11:00 pm
Re: Motorcycle batteries are a pain in the ass April 11, 2006, 10:09 am

Contact Us | Privacy Policy

XML SitemapXML Sitemap