Posted by Twibil on August 21, 2009, 3:09 pm
wrote:
> I'm thinking about getting a scooter or low powered motorcycle (possibly
> something like a Vespa) for commuting from Murrieta to South Orange County.
> The distance each way is about 50 miles (about a two hour commute, maybe
> less).
> I have a few options:
> 1. Ortega Highway
> 2 Tenaja Road
> 3. Black Star Canyon Road
> 4. Basilone Road (a little longer)
> Are any of these safe enough for a small scooter?
Considering the heavy commuter traffic flow on all those roads and the
fact that you're a beginner, not really. Small scooters are primarily
designed for 'around town' rides, and the commutes you mentioned are
somewhat risky during rush hours even on a full-sized motorcycle.
One little glitch and you're a Buick's hood ornament.
> Are there any other alternatives?
Not that show on the map.
Posted by turby on August 21, 2009, 7:08 pm
wrote:
> I'm thinking about getting a scooter or low powered motorcycle (possibly
> something like a Vespa) for commuting from Murrieta to South Orange County.
> The distance each way is about 50 miles (about a two hour commute, maybe
> less).
> I have a few options
> 1. Ortega Highway
> 2 Tenaja Road
> 3. Black Star Canyon Road
> 4. Basilone Road (a little longer)
> Are any of these safe enough for a small scooter? Are there any other
> alternatives?
There may be a ton of alternatives - that's what makes motorcycling
fun - finding the good alternatives.
Are they safe? As Twibil says, not really. If you've already done the
commute, you've seen how crazy those roads can be at commute time.
Ortega is a fun road on two wheels when there isn't a lot of traffic,
if there's trouble on the road, 2 wheels may be the only way to get to
your destination.
As for safety, that commute is OK if you're mature and learn to ride
well. That means taking not just the MSF course, but advanced training
as well. For that commute, in the first year figure that once a month
somebody will scare the crap out of you.
I disagree with the 650 min size. A 500cc motorcycle would be fine for
that. You might wish you had more power to get out of people's way, or
to make quicker passes going over the hill, though.
> Is there any chance we'll ever see an express bus from Temecula/Murrieta to
> Orange County via any of these routes?
I'd bet in another 6-10 years.
> Can I get something decent for under $1,000?
If you include decent riding gear, probably not.
But if you prorate the fun, gas mileage, travel time, and parking
ease, it's prolly worth it.
Posted by turby on August 22, 2009, 12:00 pm
> On Fri, 21 Aug 2009 11:30:52 -0700, "William R. Cousert"
> > I'm thinking about getting a scooter or low powered motorcycle (possibly
> > something like a Vespa) for commuting from Murrieta to South Orange County.
> > The distance each way is about 50 miles (about a two hour commute, maybe
> > less).
> You are talking an average speed of 25MPH!? That's a
> housing/residential speed here. Even with stop light idling, my
> Dungbeetle dash reports an average speed in the 35MPH range.
> You are also talking about 500 miles a week! If you look at Kelly
> Blue Book motorcycle guide, you'll notice that "typical" mileage for the
> under 400cc (maybe even under 500cc) is under 2000 miles a YEAR!
> > I have a few options
> > 1. Ortega Highway
> > 2 Tenaja Road
> > 3. Black Star Canyon Road
> > 4. Basilone Road (a little longer)
> What are the typical speeds (not posted speeds) on those roads?
It's interesting that you would respond to someone's direct question
about particular roads, yet have no clue what they are.
http://www.theortegahighway.com/
Googlemap it. The road is a major thoroughfare in the area, connecting
the inland communities with the coast. It has a fun bit of twisties
and goes from ~sea level to 2500' and back. It is notorious among
sportbikers, and has a fairly heavy police presence because of it. It
will occasionally get closed because of brushfires, accidents, etc.
AFAIK, the other roads are local and the last I knew didn't go all the
way through. New development may have changed that. Basilone goes
through Camp Pendleton, and I don't think there is public access.
Posted by William R. Cousert on August 22, 2009, 1:16 pm
> > AFAIK, the other roads are local and the last I knew didn't go all the
> way through. New development may have changed that. Basilone goes
> through Camp Pendleton, and I don't think there is public access.
I used Google Maps for directions and it gave me several options for my
route.
Is the Ortega Highway the only road that actually goes through all the way?
If so, there's a problem with Google's database.
If not, which of these routes is the safest?
Posted by turby on August 22, 2009, 6:04 pm
wrote:
> > > AFAIK, the other roads are local and the last I knew didn't go all the
> > way through. New development may have changed that. Basilone goes
> > through Camp Pendleton, and I don't think there is public access.
> I used Google Maps for directions and it gave me several options for my
> route.
> Is the Ortega Highway the only road that actually goes through all the way?
I'm pretty sure it is, but there's been a lot of development since I
last explored the area.
> If so, there's a problem with Google's database.
> If not, which of these routes is the safest?
OK. It seems you really are a newbie to cycling. You really shouldn't
even consider buying a scooter as small as you've suggested. You'd be
relegated to riding on the side of the road, dodging cars that are
going 50mph or more. The speed limits on Ortega AIR are ~50mph, with
several miles of twisty 2 lane. Imagine 2 trucks passing each other
with you toodling along on the edge of the pavement. OTOH, if you got
a bike with decent power and handling, and worked off-hours to avoid
traffic, that commute could be _really_ enjoyable.
The safest? The safest roads are freeways, where you need to maintain
a minimum of 45mph. That's either 91 or 76, both of which are out of
your way.
Are you a new resident? It sounds like you don't know the area at all.
If you have a car, you should drive the route a couple of weeks, then
decide if you want a scooter. I'll bet the answer is no. Anything
smaller than a 250 on that road is enough to get you into trouble, but
not enough to get you out of it.
> something like a Vespa) for commuting from Murrieta to South Orange County.
> The distance each way is about 50 miles (about a two hour commute, maybe
> less).
> I have a few options:
> 1. Ortega Highway
> 2 Tenaja Road
> 3. Black Star Canyon Road
> 4. Basilone Road (a little longer)
> Are any of these safe enough for a small scooter?