Posted by mike on July 19, 2010, 8:27 pm
'83 Honda VT500C Shadow.
IN hot weather, the battery goes dry in about 500 miles.
To put in water, I have to take off the seat, remove the battery,
fill it, reverse the process. PITA.
It's my garage sale bike, so it does sit idling a lot while
I'm browsing. The battery does get a workout.
Anything I can do to reduce the water loss or make it easier to fill?
Clever fill gadget? Getting water to it ain't hard. It's telling
when to stop adding water that's hard.
Regulator is at 14.39V. Well within
the 15V max stated in the manual.
I'd crank it down a little if I had the option.
Ideas?
Thanks, mike
Posted by Mark Olson on July 19, 2010, 8:38 pm
mike wrote:
> '83 Honda VT500C Shadow.
>
> IN hot weather, the battery goes dry in about 500 miles.
> To put in water, I have to take off the seat, remove the battery,
> fill it, reverse the process. PITA.
>
> It's my garage sale bike, so it does sit idling a lot while
> I'm browsing. The battery does get a workout.
There's absolutely no reason to leave your bike running while
you spend time at garage sales. But that is irrelevant to
the problem you describe, other than it may expose your battery
to unnecessary amounts of heat.
> Anything I can do to reduce the water loss or make it easier to fill?
> Clever fill gadget? Getting water to it ain't hard. It's telling
> when to stop adding water that's hard.
You're trying to fix the wrong problem.
> Regulator is at 14.39V. Well within
> the 15V max stated in the manual.
> I'd crank it down a little if I had the option.
The battery is being overcharged. Either the regulator is
defective or the sense line (common on Hondas) is sensing
the wrong voltage, causing the regulator to set the output
voltage of the alternator too high. Fix the connection
problem(s) or replace the regulator. Simply replacing the
regulator won't fix the problem if it's a connection issue.
I've seen this exact problem on at least two early 80s
Hondas and fixed them both the same way. The problem is that
the Kelvin sense wire goes through the ignition switch, which
has a fair amount of voltage drop through multiple connections
on an older bike with oxidized connections. So the regulator sense
line is seeing about 1V less than what the battery sees. The
fix is to either clean and/or replace all the tired connections
or re-route the sense line directly to the battery. If you
choose the latter option you need to ensure the sense line
doesn't draw excess current with the bike not running or it
can drain the battery quickly. In both cases I verified this
with a sensitive milliammeter before committing to the fix.
Posted by mike on July 20, 2010, 2:38 am
Mark Olson wrote:
> mike wrote:
>> '83 Honda VT500C Shadow.
>>
>> IN hot weather, the battery goes dry in about 500 miles.
>> To put in water, I have to take off the seat, remove the battery,
>> fill it, reverse the process. PITA.
>>
>> It's my garage sale bike, so it does sit idling a lot while
>> I'm browsing. The battery does get a workout.
>
> There's absolutely no reason to leave your bike running while
> you spend time at garage sales.
Sounds like you haven't done the math.
Start a bike 50 times a day and something that was designed to
last for many years doesn't last nearly that long.
But that is irrelevant to
> the problem you describe, other than it may expose your battery
> to unnecessary amounts of heat.
>
>> Anything I can do to reduce the water loss or make it easier to fill?
>> Clever fill gadget? Getting water to it ain't hard. It's telling
>> when to stop adding water that's hard.
>
> You're trying to fix the wrong problem.
>
>> Regulator is at 14.39V. Well within
>> the 15V max stated in the manual.
>> I'd crank it down a little if I had the option.
>
> The battery is being overcharged. Either the regulator is
> defective or the sense line (common on Hondas) is sensing
> the wrong voltage, causing the regulator to set the output
> voltage of the alternator too high. Fix the connection
> problem(s) or replace the regulator. Simply replacing the
> regulator won't fix the problem if it's a connection issue.
>
> I've seen this exact problem on at least two early 80s
> Hondas and fixed them both the same way.
Good call.
Rerouting the sense line did drop the voltage.
Should know in a week if it fixes it.
All I gotta do is remember to charge it a few times
over the winter.
My jaw is getting tired from all the bubble gum I'm
chewing to keep this thing patched up.
If I could find a 500cc water-cooled, shaft-drive
bike, I'd buy a new one. they don't make 'em
like they used to.
thanks, mike
The problem is that
> the Kelvin sense wire goes through the ignition switch, which
> has a fair amount of voltage drop through multiple connections
> on an older bike with oxidized connections. So the regulator sense
> line is seeing about 1V less than what the battery sees. The
> fix is to either clean and/or replace all the tired connections
> or re-route the sense line directly to the battery. If you
> choose the latter option you need to ensure the sense line
> doesn't draw excess current with the bike not running or it
> can drain the battery quickly. In both cases I verified this
> with a sensitive milliammeter before committing to the fix.
>
>
Posted by mike on August 1, 2010, 1:03 am
mike wrote:
> Mark Olson wrote:
>> mike wrote:
>>> '83 Honda VT500C Shadow.
>>>
>>> IN hot weather, the battery goes dry in about 500 miles.
>>> To put in water, I have to take off the seat, remove the battery,
>>> fill it, reverse the process. PITA.
>>>
>>> It's my garage sale bike, so it does sit idling a lot while
>>> I'm browsing. The battery does get a workout.
>>
>> There's absolutely no reason to leave your bike running while
>> you spend time at garage sales.
>
> Sounds like you haven't done the math.
> Start a bike 50 times a day and something that was designed to
> last for many years doesn't last nearly that long.
>
>
> But that is irrelevant to
>> the problem you describe, other than it may expose your battery
>> to unnecessary amounts of heat.
>>
>>> Anything I can do to reduce the water loss or make it easier to fill?
>>> Clever fill gadget? Getting water to it ain't hard. It's telling
>>> when to stop adding water that's hard.
>>
>> You're trying to fix the wrong problem.
>>
>>> Regulator is at 14.39V. Well within
>>> the 15V max stated in the manual.
>>> I'd crank it down a little if I had the option.
>>
>> The battery is being overcharged. Either the regulator is
>> defective or the sense line (common on Hondas) is sensing
>> the wrong voltage, causing the regulator to set the output
>> voltage of the alternator too high. Fix the connection
>> problem(s) or replace the regulator. Simply replacing the
>> regulator won't fix the problem if it's a connection issue.
>>
>> I've seen this exact problem on at least two early 80s
>> Hondas and fixed them both the same way.
>
> Good call.
> Rerouting the sense line did drop the voltage.
> Should know in a week if it fixes it.
> All I gotta do is remember to charge it a few times
> over the winter.
>
> My jaw is getting tired from all the bubble gum I'm
> chewing to keep this thing patched up.
> If I could find a 500cc water-cooled, shaft-drive
> bike, I'd buy a new one. they don't make 'em
> like they used to.
>
> thanks, mike
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> The problem is that
>> the Kelvin sense wire goes through the ignition switch, which
>> has a fair amount of voltage drop through multiple connections
>> on an older bike with oxidized connections. So the regulator sense
>> line is seeing about 1V less than what the battery sees. The
>> fix is to either clean and/or replace all the tired connections
>> or re-route the sense line directly to the battery. If you
>> choose the latter option you need to ensure the sense line
>> doesn't draw excess current with the bike not running or it
>> can drain the battery quickly. In both cases I verified this
>> with a sensitive milliammeter before committing to the fix.
>>
>>
400 miles later and the battery is still full of water.
Rerouting the sense line seems to have fixed it.
Thanks for the suggestion.
mike
Posted by The Older Gentleman on August 1, 2010, 1:05 pm
> 400 miles later and the battery is still full of water.
> Rerouting the sense line seems to have fixed it.
> Thanks for the suggestion.
Beers all round on Mike, then.
--
BMW K1100LT Ducati 750SS Triumph Street Triple Honda CB400F
Suzuki TS250 Suzuki GN250 chateaudotmurrayatidnetdotcom
Nothing damages a machine more than an ignoramus with a manual, a
can-do attitude and a set of cheap tools
>
> IN hot weather, the battery goes dry in about 500 miles.
> To put in water, I have to take off the seat, remove the battery,
> fill it, reverse the process. PITA.
>
> It's my garage sale bike, so it does sit idling a lot while
> I'm browsing. The battery does get a workout.